Posts
The Lost Art of Small Talk: Why Your Networking Sucks and How to Fix It
Most people think networking events are about collecting business cards like they're Pokémon cards from the 90s.
I've been watching business professionals stumble through networking conversations for over 18 years now, and honestly, it's painful. Like watching someone try to parallel park while blindfolded. You want to help, but you're also slightly entertained by the disaster unfolding.
Here's the thing that'll make some of you uncomfortable: small talk isn't small at all. It's actually the most important skill you're not learning. And before you roll your eyes and mutter something about authenticity, hear me out.
The Brutal Truth About First Impressions
When I first started attending industry events in Melbourne back in 2006, I thought I was brilliant at networking. I'd walk up to someone, launch straight into my elevator pitch, hand over my card, and move on to the next target. Classic rookie mistake.
Turns out, people don't give a damn about your quarterly projections when they've known you for exactly 37 seconds.
The research backs this up - though I'll spare you the academic jargon. People make decisions about trustworthiness within milliseconds of meeting you. Not minutes. Milliseconds. That weather comment you think is boring? It's actually buying you precious time to demonstrate you're not a sociopathic sales robot.
Small talk serves three critical functions that most business books completely miss:
First, it's reconnaissance. You're gathering intelligence about the person's communication style, energy level, and current mood. Are they checking their phone every 10 seconds? Probably not the best time to discuss your revolutionary blockchain solution.
Second, it's a trust test. Can you have a normal human conversation about mundane topics without being weird? This is surprisingly harder than it sounds for many professionals.
Third, it's permission-seeking behaviour. You're essentially asking for consent to continue the interaction. When someone responds positively to your opening remarks, they're signalling they're open to more substantial conversation.
Why Most Small Talk Training is Garbage
I've seen countless workshops that teach people to memorise conversation starters like "What brings you here tonight?"
Absolute rubbish.
Memorised lines make you sound like a telemarketer who's lost their script. The goal isn't to have identical conversations with every person you meet. It's to be genuinely curious about the human standing in front of you.
Here's what actually works: observation-based comments. Instead of asking generic questions, make specific observations about the immediate environment or situation. "This venue has amazing acoustics - you can actually hear yourself think" is infinitely better than "How's your evening going?"
The difference? Specificity creates connection. Generic questions create interviews.
The Australian Advantage (And Why We're Wasting It)
Australians have a natural gift for casual conversation. We're culturally predisposed to taking the piss out of pretentious situations, which is networking gold. Yet somehow, we abandon this superpower the moment we put on a name tag.
I once watched a Sydney executive spend 20 minutes at a Brisbane networking event explaining his company's market positioning. The person he was talking to was clearly desperate to escape, but too polite to interrupt. Classic Australian politeness working against natural conversation flow.
Our cultural tendency toward self-deprecating humour is actually perfect for networking. It makes you approachable and memorable. Just don't overdo it to the point where you sound like you hate your job. There's a fine line between humble and desperate.
The Topics That Actually Work
Weather gets a bad rap, but it's networking gold in Australia. Our weather is genuinely interesting - bushfires, floods, heatwaves that melt your car dashboard. It's not boring small talk when there's actual drama involved.
Current events work brilliantly, provided you avoid anything remotely political. Sports are generally safe, though be prepared for passionate responses. Food is universally engaging, especially if you can recommend local restaurants or cafés.
Travel stories are conversation platinum. Everyone has travel experiences or aspirations. Plus, it naturally leads to discovering shared connections or interests.
The Follow-Up That Everyone Forgets
Here's where 78% of networkers completely fail: the follow-up. You had a great conversation about weekend markets in Perth, exchanged cards, then never spoke again. Brilliant strategy.
The most effective managing difficult conversations happen when you reference something specific from your initial chat. Not "Great meeting you at the event" but "Hope you found that sourdough bakery in Paddington we discussed."
Specificity demonstrates you were actually listening, not just waiting for your turn to talk.
I learned this lesson the hard way after losing touch with someone who became a major client for a competitor. All because I sent a generic LinkedIn request instead of mentioning our shared frustration with Brisbane traffic.
The Technology Trap
Smartphones have murdered networking conversations. People check their devices mid-sentence now, which would have been considered socially unacceptable just 10 years ago.
Put your phone away. Completely away. Not face-down on the table where you can see notifications blinking. Away.
Your undivided attention is now such a rare gift that it's become a competitive advantage. When someone feels like they're the only person in the room that matters to you, they remember that feeling long after they've forgotten your company name.
Practice Makes Permanent (Not Perfect)
Small talk is a skill that requires practice in low-stakes environments. Start with café staff, shop assistants, or people waiting in queues. These interactions don't matter professionally, which makes them perfect training grounds.
The time management aspect is crucial too. Good networkers know when to gracefully exit conversations. You're not trying to become best friends with everyone - you're trying to create positive impressions that might lead to future opportunities.
Most people stay in conversations too long because they don't know how to leave politely. Practice transitional phrases: "I promised myself I'd circulate and meet a few more people tonight" or "I should let you get back to your colleague."
People appreciate honesty and efficient communication, especially at networking events where everyone understands the purpose.
The Contrarian View Nobody Talks About
Here's an opinion that might get me in trouble: sometimes the best networking happens when you're not actively networking.
I've made some of my most valuable professional connections in grocery store queues, coffee shops, and airport lounges. When people aren't in "networking mode," they're more genuine and receptive to authentic conversation.
The pressure to perform is removed, so real personalities emerge. That person complaining about delayed flights might be exactly the type of practical problem-solver your team needs.
What Nobody Tells You About Industry Events
Most networking advice assumes all events are created equal. They're not. Corporate events skew toward formal conversations. Startup meetups encourage casual interaction. Industry conferences fall somewhere in between.
Adjust your approach accordingly. What works at a legal symposium will bomb at a creative agency mixer. Read the room before you start talking about quarterly projections or revolutionary market disruptions.
Also, arrive early. The first 30 minutes of any event are networking gold. People are fresh, conversations are shorter, and everyone's more approachable. By the time the wine kicks in, dynamics change dramatically.
The ROI of Actually Caring
Here's the uncomfortable truth: effective networking requires genuine interest in other people. If you're faking curiosity, it shows. People can sense when they're being evaluated for their potential usefulness.
Focus on building relationships, not collecting contacts. One meaningful connection beats 20 superficial exchanges every single time. Quality over quantity isn't just good advice - it's the only approach that scales sustainably.
The most successful networkers I know follow up with people they genuinely liked, regardless of immediate business potential. That graphic designer you chatted with about weekend markets might not need your services today, but they know 47 people who might.
Related Articles: